
I don’t generally go to a cardiac surgeon to ask him for advice on what he thinks about the carpet in my house, but thanks to
Oprah Winfrey (truly the most powerful woman in America) none of us have to ask for such unsolicited advice. In fact, Fox just recently offered it - courtesy of
their cardiac surgeon Dr. Oz - with inaccurate advice about the hazards of carpet at home!
It’s probably not fair to pin this one on Oprah, but given the fact every doctor who appears on her show more than once apparently gets a consolation prize of hosting their own TV show, I felt compelled to vent toward her as well.
Of course, I’m talking about the duet of good doctors:
Dr. Phil and
Dr. Oz. Thus far, Dr. Phil has managed to stay out of the carpet bashing business. The same can not be said for our fine cardiac surgeon, Dr. Oz.
A few weeks in a segment entitled
“Health Hazards at Home” the good doctor decided he wanted to focus on hazards inside the house and before you could say “
follow the yellow brick road” this Wizard of Oz had pulled out a bunch of Petri dishes filled with mold, mildew and fungus and claimed all of it could be found in the carpet!
I mean, this was some nasty-looking stuff that looked as if it has just showed up from wiping away a third world country. And before the audience could finish all of its “ohhs” and “ahhs” Dr. Oz whips out a bottle with a skull and crossbones on it and says there is also formaldehyde in the carpet!
Dr. Oz quickly goes on to say that he’s really nervous about this stuff being in a place where kids are constantly crawling around. And right before he moves towards the kitchen to attack something else, he makes the only sensible statement of the entire program: “
So as you can see, it’s really important to keep your carpet clean”.
I don’t mean to make light of this subject, but really, when you step back and look at the whole thing in context, there is some humor to it. Except that 3.7 million television viewers watch this show on a daily basis.
It is clear that Dr. Oz – a cardiac surgeon who ranges far beyond that expertise to dispense more generalized health advice – has credible, consistent critics who voice concern with the science, or lack thereof, behind some of what he communicates. His media spokespeople often answer this criticism with sentiments such as, “
we must include a multitude of voices and opinions, even those that may be controversial.”
But in this case,
Dr. Oz – not some other voice
– made the assertions about carpet.
My initial call was to chat with a producer of the television show who was sympathetic to my disappointment in the show and the way carpet had been depicted. I explained to her many of the points you’ve seen written in this blog time and again, and that I hated that Dr. Oz had been supplied with out-of-date information, especially when it came to formaldehyde. Assuming the stuff he had in his skull and crossbones jug was
formaldehyde, the chemical hasn’t been used in the manufacture of carpet in over 20 years.
And from the looks of those Petri dishes, if that stuff truly did come out of a carpet, it probably hadn’t been cleaned in 20 years.
I went on to explain to her that the majority of carpet was synthetic which simply means it is not a food source for mold. In order for mold to grow on a piece of carpet two things must occur: an uncontrolled source of moisture and lots of dirt!
Dr. Michael Berry, the former head of
EPA’s Indoor Air Quality program, did a study that found carpet was among the last things to foster mold in an environment that was filled with dirt and moisture and concluded if your carpet has mold in it then you can bet your mold problem is out of control in other areas such as the drywall, etc.
I suggest you read
Dr. Michael Berry's study titled Carpet in the Modern Indoor Environment. Summary of a Science-Based Assesment of Carpet.
So, are you ready to get more advice about carpet health hazards at home from the likes of Dr. Oz? Let me know.
~ James